Rate this post


To proceed this week’s (not intentional however oh-so-embraceable) theme of tasty childhood meals you’ll have forgotten you like: English Muffin Pizza!

Healthy English Muffin Pizza baked in the oven for eating now or to make ahead and freeze for later placed on a sheet pan with tomato sauce, pepperoni, vegetables, and fresh basil

Complete wheat English muffins are cut up, unfold with the pizza sauce of your alternative (tomato? pesto? alfredo? It’s all truthful recreation right here), then smothered in cheese and any of your favourite pizza toppings, English Muffin Pizza is a simple, wholesome, and extremely personalizable dinner.

Whether or not you’re in want of sure-to-please meals for choosy eaters, quick and wholesome dinners for back-to-school nights, or are a grown up seeking to cook dinner your self one thing a) presentable and b) exceptionally low-maintenance, you may have a purpose to make an English Muffin Pizza.

Or, perhaps you simply have very fond reminiscences of the jingle from the Pizza Bagels commercials and wish to take a second to relive your childhood (umm…me!). These English Muffin Pizzas hit the spot there too.

Additionally, pizza. Pizza evening = joyful evening. It’s mathematical regulation.

Let’s make these English Muffin Pizzas for toddlers, for the busy dad and mom who cook dinner for them, for my fellow youngsters of the ‘90s (did anybody else develop up with these??), and for all who crave an additional grin after they take a chew of their dinner tonight. English Muffin Pizza will make you smile.

English Muffin Pizza baked in the oven for a not soggy crust and placed on a sheet pan with tomato sauce, pepperoni, vegetables, and fresh basil

About English Muffin Pizza

For these of you who didn’t spend as a lot time within the freezer part of the grocery retailer within the ‘90s as I did, English Muffin Pizza is impressed by the notorious pizza bagels that I used to beg my mother to place into her procuring cart for us (apologies if that tune is in your head now). At this time’s English Muffin Pizza is a contemporary, healthful spin on that broadly adored snack.

From a historical past standpoint, English muffins are a spin themselves! They started as a riff of on an English crumpet and have been marketed in America in some kind because the late 1850s (they have been known as toaster crumpets then). Pizza bagels didn’t come on the scene for about 100 extra years, and there are literally dueling claims as to who invented them. The earliest claimed model was a pizza cooked on a halved bagel that was baked and not using a gap…which is form of like an English muffin. Might this be the earliest iteration of the English Muffin Pizza?

Wherever it began, English Muffin Pizza satisfies the necessity for simple, snackable, kid-friendly, gratifyingly tacky goodness!

You may make English Muffin Pizzas upfront and heat them up in a wide range of methods. See beneath for make forward English Muffin Pizza instructions, in addition to tricks to cook dinner them within the oven, the toaster oven, the grill, the air fryer, and (in a pinch) the microwave.

Not soggy English Muffin Pizza on a baking sheet topped with marinara, mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, pepperonis, and fresh basil

Tips on how to Make English Muffin Pizza

Whether or not you cook dinner these English muffins within the oven (or the toaster oven!) now, or freeze them for later, the recipe begins the identical approach.

The components for this recipe mirror that of traditional pizza. Take inspiration out of your favourite pizzas, be they traditional or loopy, and use this recipe as a place to begin for any mixture of sauce, cheese, and toppings you want.

  • English Muffins. Our stand-in for the pizza crust. As a result of these home made English Muffin Pizzas are wholesome, I like to recommend utilizing complete grain English muffins with as few processed components and added sugars as potential.

Typically the least processed English Muffins are bought within the freezer part as a result of they don’t comprise preservatives to maintain them shelf-stable, so you should definitely test there too.

  • Sauce. Any form of pizza sauce you want!

We made our English Muffin Pizza with tomato sauce. This summer time, English Muffin Pizza with pesto sauce can be gentle and seasonal. For a extra indulgent twist, attempt English Muffin Pizza with alfredo (this creamy pumpkin pasta sauce is a wholesome spin on the alfredo possibility). It’s also possible to go wild and make an English Muffin Pizza with BBQ sauce (this home made barbecue sauce is especially glorious).

  • Cheese. For essentially the most traditional method, make you English Muffin Pizza with recent mozzarella, although it’s actually not your solely possibility. This recipe is flexible and a good way to mess around with completely different cheeses or deplete additional cheeses you may have in your fridge from different recipes.

Attempt English Muffin Pizza with cheddar cheese for an all-American twist (nice with BBQ sauce!), English Muffin Pizza with ricotta for a extra Italian model (dreamy with pesto), or do a mix.

  • Toppings. Something goes right here! We nonetheless had mini-pepperonis leftover from my Zucchini Pizza Boats, in order that’s what we used.

For a meat-lovers’ model, attempt English Muffin Pizza with sausage (or sausage and pepperoni). Craving one thing enjoyable? Go Hawaiian and make English Muffin Pizza with pineapple and ham (this model can be yummy with BBQ sauce oo).

One among my favourite issues about this English Muffin Pizza recipe is how versatile it’s. Every member of your loved ones can customise to his or her style. As a result of the recipe is straightforward, it’s a enjoyable approach to contain your children within the kitchen—particularly useful in case you are making English Muffin Pizza for toddlers and hoping they’ll take a chew.

Healthy English Muffin Pizza toasting on a baking sheet for not soggy crust

The Key to Avoiding Soggy English Muffin Pizza

The most important problem with English Muffin Pizza (aside from narrowing down the entire scrumptious topping prospects) is ensuring that it doesn’t prove soggy.

The important thing to creating English Muffin Pizza not soggy is toasting the English muffins earlier than you add the sauce or toppings.

You don’t have to toast the English muffins totally. A couple of minutes within the oven will create a flippantly toasty floor barrier that permits some, however not the entire sauce to soak up. That is trick to making sure your last English Muffin Pizza is pleasantly crisp with out being dry or cracker-like, identical to the frozen pizza snack that impressed them…besides your home made English Muffin Pizza goes to style WAY higher and be higher for you too!

Healthy English Muffin Pizza with toppings for baking in the oven or to make ahead and freeze for later placed on a sheet pan with tomato sauce, pepperoni, vegetables, and fresh basil

Remaining Recipe Steps

When you’ve toasted your English muffins, you’re able to high and bake. For ease, I pre-toast the English muffins, add the toppings, after which totally bake all of them on the identical baking sheet. That is one-pan cooking at its best.

  • Unfold the English muffins together with your sauce of alternative.
  • Sprinkle on any and all desired toppings.
  • Bake the English Muffin Pizzas at 400 levels F for 10 minutes, till the cheese is melted and the English muffins are flippantly golden on the edges.

Make-Forward English Muffin Pizza – Tips on how to Prep Now, Retailer, and Eat Later

Whereas these straightforward English Muffin Pizzas are nice for quick dinners, you can even make them upfront and pace up dinner much more! Freezing them will yield the perfect outcomes.

Make Forward and Reheating Instructions – Oven Technique

  • To Freeze: That is the perfect methodology for making your English Muffin Pizza forward. Toast your English muffin halves as directed and high as desired. Lay the English Muffin Pizzas topping facet up on a parchment-lined baking sheet and place within the freezer for at the very least 2 hours. As soon as utterly frozen, place the pizzas in a freezer-safe container, separating layers of English Muffin Pizzas with parchment paper. 
  • Reheat from Frozen: Preheat your oven to 375 levels F. Lay your frozen English Muffin Pizza on a baking sheet topping facet up and place within the oven. Bake for 13 to 15 minutes, or till heated via.
  • To Refrigerate: In a single layer, place your English Muffin Pizzas within the fridge in an hermetic container topping facet up for as much as 1 week. 

Different Cooking Strategies

  • Toaster Oven. Excellent for making a smaller batch of English Muffin Pizzas! To make English Muffin Pizza in a toaster oven, warmth your toaster oven to 400 levels F and observe recipe directions for making ready English muffin halves with olive oil. Place your English muffin halves within the toaster oven for two to three minutes. Then, high with components of your alternative and place the English Muffin Pizza again into the toaster oven. Prepare dinner for 13 to 15 minutes, or till cheese is melted and edges of the muffin are flippantly golden. To reheat English Muffin Pizza within the toaster oven, warmth your toaster oven to 400 levels F and place your English Muffin Pizzas within the toaster oven for Four to five minutes, or till cheese is melted.
  • Microwave. I don’t advocate cooking English Muffin Pizza within the microwave totally, because the bottoms will change into soggy. In a pinch, for those who don’t have entry to an oven whenever you wish to heat them again up (say you’re reheating them on the workplace for lunch), you may reheat them in a microwave. Line a microwave safe-plate with a paper towel (this may take in a number of the moisture and deter the English Muffin Pizza from changing into soggy). Heat on reasonable warmth, simply till the cheese is melted.
  • Grill. To make your English Muffin Pizza on the grill, flip your grill to low warmth and place the English muffin halves on the grill rack. Watching carefully, toast halves gently till barely crispy and toasted. Instantly take away from grill and high with the sauce, cheese, and toppings of your alternative. Spray a sheet of aluminum foil (massive sufficient in your English Muffin Pizza halves) with nonstick cooking spray and lay it onto the grill. Place your English Muffin Pizza halves on the foil, topping facet up. Shut the grill and let your pizzas cook dinner for Three to Four minutes, checking them regularly. As soon as your cheese is melted, take away the pizzas from the grill and serve instantly.
  • Air Fryer. Whereas I haven’t personally tried the English Muffin Pizza air fryer method, I do know this equipment has change into fairly well-liked! From what I’ve learn, you may cook dinner English Muffin Pizza in an air fryer. Set the air fryer to 400 levels F. As soon as preheated, place your English muffins halves inside for 1 minute. Take away after 1 minute and canopy every half with desired toppings. When prepared, place your halves again into the air fryer for an extra Four minutes. To reheat the English Muffin Pizzas within the air fryer, preheat it to 320 levels F. As soon as heated to temperature, place your English Muffin Pizza inside for Three to Four minutes, or till cheese is melted.

Healthy not soggy English Muffin Pizza on a baking sheet topped with marinara, pepperoni, mushrooms, mozzarella, and fresh basil

Of all of the English Muffin Pizza we made, my favourite was the sautéed mushrooms and spinach with pepperoni model. It’s ‘90s picky-eater Erin (lover of pepperoni pizza…and little else) meets grown-up Erin (lover of greens…and mini pepperonis).

And grown-up Erin actually isn’t too mature to eat English Muffin Pizza for dinner and love each chew (and, I hope she by no means shall be!).

Simple, kid-approved English Muffin Pizza! Excellent for quick dinners, lunches, and wholesome snacks. Ideas for a not soggy crust and to make forward and freeze.

  • 4 complete wheat English muffins — cut up
  • 1/2 tablespoon additional virgin olive oil
  • 3/4 cup ready pizza sauce — tomato, pesto, or alfredo; whichever your loved ones likes! (We use tomato)
  • Tiny Pinch kosher salt
  • Pinch black pepper
  • 1 cup shredded part-skim mozzarella cheese — or cheddar cheese, provolone, or any cheese you want
  • 1/2 teaspoon Italian seasoning
  • Toppings of alternative — akin to mini pepperonis (or common pepperonis, quartered), or sautéed veggies, akin to spinach or mushrooms
  • Thinly sliced recent basil — non-compulsory for serving
  1. Preheat the oven to 400 levels F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

  2. Prepare the English muffin halves reduce facet up onto a baking sheet. Frivolously drizzle with olive oil. Place within the oven and toast till barely golden, about Four minutes.

  3. Spoon 1 1/2 tablespoons pizza sauce over every one, utilizing the again of a spoon to unfold it evenly. Sprinkle with salt and pepper. Prime with mozzarella cheese and Italian seasoning. Add any desired toppings.

  4. Bake for 10 minutes, till the cheese is melted and the muffins are browned on the sides. Prime with recent basil. Take pleasure in scorching.

  • TO REFRIGERATE: In a single layer, place your English Muffin Pizzas in an hermetic container topping facet up for as much as one week. 
  • TO FREEZE/MAKE AHEAD: Toast you English muffin halves as directed and high as desired. Lay the English Muffin Pizzas topping facet up on a baking sheet and place within the freezer for at the very least two hours. As soon as utterly frozen, place every pizza in a freezer-safe container, separating layers of English Muffin Pizzas with parchment paper. 
  • REHEAT FROM FROZEN: Preheat your oven to 375 levels F. Lay your frozen English Muffin Pizzas on a baking sheet and place within the oven. Bake for 13 to 15 minutes, or till heated via.

Course: Primary Course

Delicacies: American, Italian

Key phrase: english muffin pizzas, for toddlers, wholesome, make forward, not soggy

Vitamin Info

Quantity per serving (1 pizza) — Energy: 107, Fats: 4g, Saturated Fats: 2g, Ldl cholesterol: 9mg, Sodium: 311mg, Potassium: 148mg, Carbohydrates: 13g, Fiber: 2g, Sugar: 3g, Protein: 6g, Vitamin A: 167%, Vitamin C: 2%, Calcium: 190%, Iron: 1%

 

This put up accommodates some affiliate hyperlinks, which implies that I make a small fee off gadgets you buy at no extra price to you.